Manhattan Gyros & Subs Information

If you're ever in Gainesville and craving a satisfying, no-frills meal, Manhattan Gyros & Subs is definitely worth a visit. Tucked away at 490 NE 23rd Ave, this spot is a local favorite that serves up a fantastic selection of Mediterranean and American diner-style dishes, all with a laid-back vibe that makes it perfect for a quick bite or a casual lunch.

The moment you walk in, you're greeted by a cozy, welcoming atmosphere-it's clear that this place is all about comfort. The smell of sizzling meat on the grill mixes with the warmth of the surroundings, making it hard to resist checking out the menu right away. While they offer a range of dishes, their gyros are the stars of the show. Whether you’re a fan of lamb, chicken, or beef, the gyro wraps here are nothing short of amazing. The meat is always tender, well-seasoned, and wrapped in a fresh, soft pita with just the right balance of crisp veggies and tangy tzatziki sauce.

But if you’re not in the mood for a gyro, there are plenty of other options to choose from. Their subs are packed with flavor, from the classic Philly cheesesteak to their Italian sub, loaded with all the right ingredients. The bread is always fresh, and the fillings are generous. For something lighter, you can’t go wrong with a Greek salad, which is always piled high with fresh vegetables, feta, and olives-perfectly paired with their house-made dressing.

Service here is always friendly and fast. Whether you're getting your meal to-go or sitting down to eat, the staff makes sure you're taken care of without feeling rushed. The staff’s warmth adds to the overall feeling of comfort that you get at Manhattan Gyros & Subs. It’s the kind of place where you can enjoy your meal at your own pace, without feeling like you’re on a clock.

The restaurant also does a great job at offering some variety. They have daily specials that are always worth checking out, and there's usually something for everyone, whether you're in the mood for a hearty sandwich or something lighter. Don’t skip their fries either-crispy and golden on the outside with a soft, fluffy interior, they’re the perfect side to any meal.

For those who live in the Gainesville area or are just passing through, Manhattan Gyros & Subs offers a solid dining experience that blends quick service with great food. It’s a neighborhood gem that delivers on flavor without the fuss, and it's clear that the locals appreciate what it brings to the table. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, you’re sure to leave satisfied.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Seems to be a former Arby's or other fast food place converted. I had the Gyro Bowl, if this is any indication on the rest of the food here, I'd say anything on the Menu is fair game! This place is definitely Wolf approved 4 paws up!

How. How do you make the wings so perfect? Every single time I treat myself to some wings, I think "well they can't be as good as last time", and every time, I am wrong. The perfect spicy tangy buffalo sauce. Crispy wings that hold their crunch till you get them home. My compliments to the chef, you have achieved wing mastery. I also get the gyro and baklava, those are also good but I have to remember to ask 'light white sauce' for the gyro because theirs is quite thick for my preference. Still a banger gyro. The baklava is shatter crisp and wonderful, well balanced sweetness! The building looks a little creepy, ignore it. Treasure lies within!

Really enjoyed this place! The staff were super nice and made us feel very welcome from the start. Service was fast, and the food came out surprisingly quick. Portions are very generous — you definitely get your money’s worth. Everything was fresh, tasted great, and all the food is halal, which is a big plus. Overall, such a good experience with great food and friendly people. I’ll definitely be back and would recommend it to anyone looking for a solid halal spot to eat.

It looks kind of sketchy on the outside, but don't let that stop you! Inside was clean, the food was great, and the service was very friendly. They have a large menu so you're sure to find something you like. We had the lamb gyro combo and some gizzards. The gyros are packed full of meat! You definitely get your money's worth. The fries have a slight seafood taste- probably cooked in the same oil. It didn't bother us, but it might not be for everyone. The gizzards tasted fresh and were seasoned well. Overall absolutely would recommend

This place is legit. I ordered a lamb gyro from the drive thru—the service was excellent and the food came out quick. I was planning on taking the gyro home and eating it there but figured one bite wouldn’t hurt. After one bite, I parked in the lot and devoured the whole thing in 5 minutes. They have the best gyro in Gainesville in my opinion, and it’s one of the cheaper ones. I’ll be back soon. Update: I came back to dine in this time. I didn’t think this place could get any better, until I tried the fries.

One of my students raved about this place, so I had to try it. The staff was great and very welcoming. Being that it was my husband and I’s first time, the cashier helped us navigate through the menu. They have an amazing selection of different types of food from gyros, pastas to seafood. They give HUGE portions and our food was seasoned to perfection, straight from the kitchen! We will definitely be back! Do yourselves a favor run, don’t walk to Manhattan’s!

I can’t understate how amazing this place is. It’s in an odd part of town but is absolutely worth the drive. The menu is super expansive and everything is amazingly priced for the quality of the food. I’ve been here twice now, and both times got the #1 gyro combo. It comes with fries and a massive gyro for only $12. I couldn’t believe the price for the portion size, but i’m not complaining at all. The meat was extremely tender and well seasoned, and the fries also had a seasoning which was great. It’s the best greek food i’ve had in my 5 years in gainesville and I wholeheartedly recommend it.

They have a location in ocala that is ALWAYS busy. This location is just as good. Outside looks a little sketchy but dont let that stop you. The food is very good. GYRO and Philly cheeses steak are my favorite. Wings are good also.

Manhattan Gyros & Subs